This thread is about Eragon/Eldest/Whatever.

Liz, would you mind telling me at what point in Eldest you thought the story got stronger?

In my opinion the longer the story went on, the weaker and more predictible it got. By the end I was dissapointed enough that I have no intentions of finishing the series, which is something I almost never do. I really felt that the author's age and inexperience showed through fairly strongly.

When his "brother" punched him in the face. The FIRST fist action you see in either book.

To each his/her own, I suppose.

Silly Lizzie wrote:

When his "brother" punched him in the face. The FIRST fist action you see in either book.

That sentence. My mind is dirty


I might read the books when I cbf, read some dogey books lately ):

Hazel wrote:

To each his/her own, I suppose.

I'm making FUN of it Hazy, don't worry. I did enjoy him being completely fixed (No matter how many plotholes it leaves...) and reading how he reacted to the change.